In asnwer to Sparty, agreed. Mostly. The real issue for me is to what extent does government protect and insulate from market forces.
I started a thread on the Millennuin Town park ages ago and advocated the importance of regenerating that very run down part of St. Helier. I did so because I grew up around there and my family still live there so I know how important a catalyst it would be for change, and not just in environmental terms but social also. In fact my family have been involved with supporting the concept since the start, some 15 years ago. I'm street!
And because of that I can put my hand on my heart and say that I'm 90% sure that nobody living on or around Bath Street would have any grave concerns about the impact on the area if a third supermarket were to be installed on the Odeon site - so long as the town park project was delivered as originally promised by the States.
So I'm all for more consumer choice, lower prices, a better standard of living for town residents and for the protection of the environment that we currently can enjoy.
The only real concern I've got, having read a couple of UK reports, is the impact that companies like Tesco's and Sanisbury's have had on regional town centres. But I guess we need to leave something for the politicians to work out for themselves? Wake up Timmy?
Check out this article which spells out the dangers
http://www.monbiot.com/archives/2009/08/10/tesco-opted/ and from which many of the arguments featured will ironically also be seized upon by Ray Shead and his COC mates.